At the 1900 International Congress of Mathematicians, held that year in Paris, the German mathematician David Hilbert put forth a list of 23 unsolved problems that he saw as being the greatest challenges for twentieth-century mathematics. Found inside – Page iThis volume includes selected lectures presented at the conference, and additional contributions offering diverse perspectives from art and architecture, the philosophy and history of mathematics, and current mathematical practice. in part) by anyone interested in pursuing research in mathematics. David Hilbert put forth 23 problems that helped set the research agenda for mathematics in the 20th century. Here is a status report on those challenges. At a conference in Paris in 1900, the German mathematician David Hilbert presented a list of unsolved problems in mathematics. In 1900, the mathematician David Hilbert had proposed a list of 23 problems for the new century to grapple with. List the Hilbert College, federal code 002735, on the form. In doing so he expressed optimism about the field, sharing his feeling that unsolved problems were a sign of vitality, encouraging more people to do more research. A.S. Wightman, "Hilbert's sixth problem" F.E. 2) The compatibility of the arithmetical axioms. The problems are both extremely difficult and in a number of cases somewhat open-ended or vague, making it difficult to say what point would have to be reached to consider the problem “solved”. lished problems is, roughly: 2 to Logic, 3 to Geometry, 7 to Number Theory, 10 to Analysis/Geometry, and 1 to Physics (and its foundations). 22 - Uniformization of analytic relations by means of automorphic functions. Hilbert developed a lifelong friendship. Lie groups. Arnol'd, Yu.S. …rests on a list of 23 research problems he enunciated in 1900 at the International Mathematical Congress in Paris. This problem links to the twentieth problem through the Euler–Lagrange equation of the variational calculus, see Euler equation. A major mathematician discussed progress on each Media in category "Hilbert's problems". Bernstein, "Sur la nature analytique des solutions des équations aux dérivées parteilles des second ordre", L. Bieberbach, "Über die Bewegungsgruppen des, R. Bricard, "Sur une question de géométrie relative aux polyèdres", "Mathematical developments arising from Hilbert's problems" F.E. [a25], [a27]. See also, Boundary value problem, complex-variable methods; Boundary value problem, elliptic equations; Boundary value problem, ordinary differential equations; Boundary value problem, partial differential equations; Boundary value problems in potential theory; Plateau problem. Solving any one of these is a relatively sure way to mathematical immortality, and today only 3 remain unsolved. A monohedral tiling is a tiling in which all tiles are congruent to one fixed set $T$. The compatibility of the arithmetical axioms. , Geest&Portig (1979) (In Russian) (New ed. Why might a list of questions be so important? William Yandell has done a wonderful job in explaining the development of some significant mathematics as a by product of reviewing the work on Hilbert's problems. Hilbert's tenth problem is to give a computing algorithm which will tell of a given polynomial Diophantine equation with integer coefficients whether or not it has a solutioninintegers. problem and how work on the problem has influenced mathematics. All this concerns Abelian field extensions. See also Voronoi lattice types; Geometry of numbers. A large part of [a14] is devoted to Hilbert's seventh problem and related questions. Found insideThis collection of essays reflects the breadth of research in computer science. Following a biography of Robin Milner it contains sections on semantic foundations; programming logic; programming languages; concurrency; and mobility. The tendency to replace words with symbols and vague concepts with strict axiomatics was not yet very pronounced and would only allow the next generation of mathematicians to formalise their subject more strongly. Problem . . This represents the historically first instance of the Hasse principle. These are a type of function that adds together infinitely many numbers. But the list includes many other famour names including Wilhelm Ackermann, Felix Bernstein, Otto Blumenthal, Richard Courant, Haskell Curry, Max Dehn, Rudolf Fueter, Alfred Haar, Georg Hamel, Erich Hecke, Earle Hedrick, Ernst Hellinger, Edward Kasner, Oliver Kellogg, Hellmuth Kneser, Otto Neugebauer, Erhard Schmidt, Hugo Steinhaus, and Teiji Takagi. 6 is considered as a problem in physics rather than in mathematics. His first and second problems eventually ended up being “solved” only once people figured out what Kurt Gödel was going on about with his incompleteness theorems. Il'yashenko, "Ordinary differential equations" D.V. Building up of space from congruent polyhedra. Soc. Comment document.getElementById("comment").setAttribute( "id", "a7b84497103dfcfb208aa64cce8935d6" );document.getElementById("f05c6f46e1").setAttribute( "id", "comment" ); The SciHi Blog is made with enthusiasm by. Hilbert remained there for the rest of his life. The latter problem was solved by V.I. The withdrawn 24 would also be in this class. In 1895, as a result of intervention on his behalf by Felix Klein, he obtained the position of Professor of Mathematics at the University of Göttingen [6]. Found insideThe series is aimed specifically at publishing peer reviewed reviews and contributions presented at workshops and conferences. Each volume is associated with a particular conference, symposium or workshop. A.W. MATHEMATICAL PROBLEMS DAVID HILBERT Lecture delivered before the International Congress of Mathematicians at Paris in 1900. Who of us would not be glad to lift the veil behind which the future lies hidden; to cast a glance at the next advances of our science and at the secrets of its development His opinion about Fermat's problem was right. Please note that the content of this book primarily consists of articles available from Wikipedia or other free sources online. The motivation came from positive answers in a number of important cases where there is a group$G$ acting on $k^n$ and $K$ is the field of $G$-invariant rational functions. First English translation of revolutionary paper (1931) that established that even in elementary parts of arithmetic, there are propositions which cannot be proved or disproved within the system. Introduction by R. B. Braithwaite. Your email address will not be published. The Hilbert problems. This theory was origi nated at the end of the nineteenth century in the works of two geniuses of the world science: of the Russian mathematician A. M. Lyapunov and of the French mathematician Henri Poincare. Hilbert remained at the University of Königsberg as a Privatdozent (senior lecturer) from 1886 to 1895. (1998), R. Roussarie, "Bifurcation of planar vectorfields and Hilbert's sixteenth problem" , Birkhäuser (1998), C.-H. Sah, "Hilbert's third problem: scissors congruence" , Pitman (1979), S. Sawin, "Links, quantum groups, and TQFT's", H.C.H. Its algebraic-geometric analogue, the Weil conjectures, were settled by P. Deligne (1973). Solved in the negative sense by Hilbert's student M. Dehn (actually before Hilbert's lecture was delivered, in 1900; [a11]) and R. Bricard (1896; [a8]). new problems of importance were described. The amount of work accomplished since is enormous in achievement and volume and includes generalized solution ideas such as distributions (see Generalized function) and, rather recently (1998) for the non-linear case, generalized function algebras [a30], [a37], [a38]. For a much simplified (but non-standard) treatment, see [a20]. 20 - The general problem of boundary curves. However, Euclid's list of axioms was still far from being complete; Hilbert's list is … Problem Hilberts list of problems is way less clear-cut than you think. Schubert, "Kalkül der abzählenden Geometrie" , Teubner (1879). However, Kurt Gödel‘s second incompleteness theorem gives a precise sense in which such a finitistic proof of the consistency of arithmetic is probably impossible. 14. The published version [a18] contains 23 problems, though at the meeting Hilbert discussed but ten of them (problems 1, 2, 6, 7, 8, 13, 16, 19, 21, 22). The Hasse–Minkowski theorem (see Quadratic form) reduces the classification of quadratic forms over a global field to that over local fields. Hilbert's 10th Problem 7 Before Turing Here is the list of the 23 problems: 1) Cantor's problem of the cardinal number of the continuum. In 1900, the general matter of boundary value problems and generalized solutions to differential equations, as Hilbert wisely specified, was in its very beginning. Hilbert's 23 problems are the most influential lists of open problems of all time Hilbert outlined 23 major problems to be studied in the coming century. Solved by A.M. Gleason and D. Montgomery and L. Zippin, (1952; [a15], [a29]), in the form of the following theorem: Every locally Euclidean topological group is a Lie group and even a real-analytic group (see also Analytic group; Topological group). Problem 9 - Proof of the most general law of reciprocity in any number field. 15 - Rigorous foundation of Schubert's calculus. Many of the problems in Hilbert’s list are – partly also for this reason – not formulated so precisely and restrictedly that they could be clearly solved by the publication of a proof. Hilbert, David, 1862–1943. taggedwiki.zubiaga.org/new_content/04996fc1b36cadb89ef21f403e285c12 The complexity of the brain and the protean nature of behaviour remain the most elusive but important area of science. The editors invited 23 experts from the many areas of systems neuroscience to formulate one problem each. This is generally reckoned the most successful and deeply considered compilation of open problems ever to be produced by an individual mathematician. Cantor's problem on the cardinal number of the continuum. Found insideThe present volume sets forth the official description of each of the seven problems and the rules governing the prizes. It also contains an essay by Jeremy Gray on the history of prize problems in mathematics. Turaev, "Quantum invariants of knots and 3-manifolds" , W. de Gruyter (1994) pp. On the other hand, problems 1, 2, 5, 9, 15, 18+ (the “+” stands for a computer-generated proof), and 22 have solutions that have partial acceptance, but there exists some controversy as to whether it resolves the problem or not. 2015, 263) Expanding on this theme, the RB&B editors remarked on the social and collaborative aspect of all sciences and the need for an ongoing, frank, and open discussion to address what they called “Big Questions,” which. See Variational calculus for developments in the theory of variational problems as classically understood; see Variational calculus in the large for the global analysis problems that emerged later. See also Equal content and equal shape, figures of. the symposium was edited by Felix Browder and published by the American The original version in the way Hilbert stated it ( Hilbert 1901) is the following (translated from the original German): 6. See also Set theory. See Zeta-function. After his high school graduation, in autumn 1880, Hilbert enrolled at the University of Königsberg, the “Albertina”. In dimensions $10$, $11$ and $13$ there are packings that are denser than any lattice packing. In 1900, David Hilbert published a list of 23 problems that he proposed would be the important ones for mathematicians to solve in the upcoming century. Hilbert’s 7th Problem Let ;2C. The dimension-one case was solved by H. Poincaré and P. Koebe (1907) in the form of the Koebe general uniformization theorem: A Riemann surface topologically equivalent to a domain in the extended complex plane is also conformally equivalent to such a domain, and the Poincaré-Koebe theorem or Klein–Poincaré uniformization theorem (see Uniformization; Discrete group of transformations). . Functional analysis, which was founded among others by Hilbert himself with the introduction of the Hilbert space named after him, had not yet separated itself from the calculus of variations as a mathematical field. : H. Deutsch, 1998), D.V. 1900. The full list of 23 problems appeared in the paper published in the Proceedings of the conference. Proof of the most general law of reciprocity in any number field. 3 - The equality of two volumes of two tetrahedra of equal bases and At the International Congress of Mathematics in the year 1900 in Paris, David Hilbert gave a talk in which he stated 23 open problems that he regarded central for the development of mathematics. David Hilbert gave a talk at the International Congress of Mathematicians in Paris on 8 August 1900 in which he described 10 from a list of 23 problems. The two-volume proceedings of To date 16 of these have been either solved or given counterexamples. The complete list of 23 problems was published later, most notably in English translation in 1902 by Mary Frances Winston Newson in the Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society. Soc. Abstract: This exposition is primarily a survey of the elementary yet subtle innovations of several mathematicians between 1929 and 1934 that led to partial and then complete solutions to Hilbert's Seventh Problem (from the International Congress of Mathematicians in Paris, 1900). S. Yakovenko (ed.) On the other hand, problems 1, 2, 5, 9, 15, 18+ (the “+” stands for a computer-generated proof), and 22 have solutions that have partial acceptance, but there exists some controversy as to whether it resolves the problem or not. Hilbert’s list. hypothesis); the problem of the straight line as the shortest distance 7 - Irrationality and transcendence of certain numbers. The interlocking lives of two very different and unique men have been brought together for the first time in this combined edition of Constance Reid's two popular books. . Solved by E. Artin (1927; see Reciprocity laws). See Desargues geometry and [a35], [a47]. Idea. At yovisto academic search engine you can listen to Prof. Angus MacIntyre from Gresham College, London, asking ‘What has become of Hilbert’s problems a century later?‘ and ‘How will the story continue?`, Your email address will not be published. See also Class field theory, which also is relevant for the 12th problem. See [a3], [a22], [a23], [a39]. Problem 18 - Building space from congruent polyhedra. Hilbert stated his nine­teenth prob­lem as a reg­u­lar­ity prob­lem for a class of el­lip­tic par­tial dif­fer­en­tial equa­tion with an­a­lytic coefficients, there­fore the first ef­forts of the re­searchers who sought to solve it were di­rected to study the reg­u­lar­ity of clas­si­cal so­lu­tions for equa­tions be­long­ing to this class. Let 6= 1 6= 0. [5] Hilbert obtained his doctorate in 1885, with a dissertation titled Über invariante Eigenschaften spezieller binärer Formen, insbesondere der Kugelfunktionen (“On the invariant properties of special binary forms, in particular the spherical harmonic functions“). In 1886 Hilbert habilitated himself in Königsberg with a thesis on invariant theoretical investigations in the field of binary forms and became a private lecturer. Irrationality and Transcendence of Certain Numbers: Is ab transcendental, for algebraic a ≠ 0,1 and irrational … This 2004 book presents a fascinating collection of problems related to the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality and coaches readers through solutions. mathematical Society in 1976. He found a numerical invariant, now called the Dehn invariant, that has the same value on any two equidecomposable polyhedra but has di erent values on a regular tetrahedron and a cube. iv Problems of prime numbers (cf. Kolmogorov (1956–1957; see Composite function): Each continuous function of $n$ variables can be written as a composite (superposition) of continuous functions of two variables. These 23 problems, together with short, mainly bibliographical comments, are briefly listed below, using the short title descriptions from [a19]. (ed.) . ISBN 978-1-4704-1564-8 (alk. This book focuses on finiteness conjectures and results in ordinary differential equations (ODEs) and Diophantine geometry. Found insideThe goal in putting together this unique compilation was to present the current status of the solutions to some of the most essential open problems in pure and applied mathematics. The above quote is, in fact, a bastardization of the opening statements of Hilbert's speech. A counterexample, precisely in this setting of rings of invariants, was given by M. Nagata (1959). II. $\begingroup$ Continuing on with the "advancement of science" theme, there was a Quanta article from 2018 ("A Classical Math Problem Gets Pulled Into the Modern World") that describes how Hilbert's 17th problem plays a role in certain "real-world" optimization problems. For instance, $2^{\sqrt 2}$ and $e^\pi = i^{-2i}$. Hilbert’s fifth problem and related topics / Terence Tao. Since the first volume of this work came out in Germany in 1937, this book, together with its first volume, has remained standard in the field. This list achieved great celebrity among mathematicians, and at least nine of the problems have now been solved. . at Northern Illinois University on the Mathematical developments arising . 6 - Mathematical treatment of the axioms of physics. R. Tijdeman, "The Gel'fond–Baker method" F.E. Problem Mathematics is not like a game whose tasks are determined by arbitrarily stipulated rules. Though there were already in 1900 a great many results in the calculus of variations, very much more has been developed since. What particular goals will there be toward which the leading mathematical spirits of coming generations will strive? Pogorelov, "A complete solution of Hilbert's fourth problem", A.V. Problem . Lie algebras. Problem The analogous question for function fields was settled by I.R. [a28], [a41], [a44], [a45], [a50], [a52]. Using words that recall Hilbert’s, Andr´e Weil (1906–1998) once said, “Great prob-lems furnish the daily bread on which the mathematician thrives” [105, p. 324]. 16 - Problem of the topology of algebraic curves and surfaces. Indeed, one version of another such idea is often the basis of definitions in singular cases. , Amer. problems. Shafarevich (the Shafarevich reciprocity law, 1948); see [a46]. Irrationality and transcendence of certain numbers. Hilbert's sixth problem Last updated November 16, 2020. also Prime number). Part I", I.G. The work contains applications of the technique developed for that solution and describes the improvements of the original proof since the problem was "unsolved" 20 years ago. 3. E. Schulte, "Tilings" P.M. Gruber (ed.) Hilbert’s address to International Congress. [9] Famously, Hilbert stated that the point is to know one way or the other what the solution is and he believed that we always can know this, i.e., that in mathematics there is no “ignorabimus” (Latin for “we will not know”or a statement that the truth can never be known). The study of this problem led to the theory of formally real fields (see also Ordered field). Mathematics at the turn of the century was not yet well established. Problem Although almost a century Of the 23 Hilbert problems, problems 3, 7, 10, 11, 13, 14, 17, 19, 20, and 21 have a solution that is accepted by consensus. Kapranov, "Analogies between the Langlands correspondence and topological quantum field theory" S. Gindikhin (ed.) The subgroups in question are now called Bieberbach groups, see (the editorial comments to) Space forms. Hilbert’s address provided what was essentially his view of what the new century could and, he hoped, would bring: 1. J.M. Deciding which outstanding problems in mathematics are the most important is to decide the course of mathematics’ future development. In the 120 years since Hilbert’s talk, some of his problems, typically referred to by number, have been solved and some are still open, but most important, they have spurred … For degree six this was finally solved by D.A. In the 1920's Hilbert ran a seminar in Atomic Physics and all the latest discoveries in Physics and enticed the greatest active scientists, including Einstein, to give talks. These became famous as Hilbert’s 23 problems and have indeed considerably influenced mathematics in the 20th century.. The tenth of these problems asked to perform the following: Given a Diophantine equation with any number of unknown quan-tities and with rational integral numerical coe cients: To devise a . . Lie's concept of a continuous group of transformations without the assumption of the differentiability of the functions defining the group. Mathematical Treatment of the Axioms of Physics. Solved by A.O. See the standard reference [a10]. In 1900 the conference took place in Paris and David Hilbert gave a talk where he presented a list of 23 mathematical problems which he considered to be of special importance. Determination of the solvability of a Diophantine equation. Matiyasevic proved that there is no such algorithm. Following Frege [1] and Bertrand Russell,[2] Hilbert sought to define mathematics logically using the method of formal systems, i.e., finitistic proofs from an agreed-upon set of axioms. Several of the problems still remain open. The sixth in the famous list of Hilbert's problems asks for the formalization/ axiomatization of physics in mathematics. also Riemann hypotheses) and is the most famous and important of the yet (1998) unsolved conjectures in mathematics. . Soc. The question of if there is a transfinite number … G. Segal, "Geometric aspects of quantum field theory" , I.R. Proposed a list of 23 unsolved problems to the International Congress of Mathematics in Paris. Partially solved. 2015, 263). Chap. This book explores the rich and deep interplay between mathematics and physics one century after David Hilbert’s works from 1891 to 1933, published by Springer in six volumes. There also exists convex anisohedral pentagons, [a26]. Final solution by A.V. from Hilbert problems. The full list of the 23 problems was published in … Arnol'd (ed.) 19 - Are the solutions of regular problems in the calculus of variations David Hilbert's 24 Problems. Lie's concept of a continuous group of transformations without the assumption of the differentiability of the … I understand that Hilbert, Lebesgue and Tonelli were pioneers in this area. Solved by the work of L. Plemelj, G. Birkhoff, I. Lappo-Danilevskij, P. Deligne, and A. Bolibrukh (see Fuchsian equation; [a2], [a5], [a12]). paper) 1. On the other hand, this circle of problems is still is a very lively topic (as of 1998), see [a43] for a recent survey. “We are not speaking here of arbitrariness in any sense. Hilbert's tenth problem is the tenth in the famous list which Hilbert gave in his These problems gave focus for the exponential development of mathematical thought over the following century. The task of explaining Hilbert's problems and their solutions for perhaps a general audience is not an easy one. Hilbert’s Problems are more than a list of unsolved mathematical riddles. It outlined his philosophy M. Werner (ed.) Proof of the existence of linear differential equations having a prescribed monodromy group. "Cantor's problem of the cardinal number of the continuum." V.I. Perhaps the mathematician who had the greatest impact on the direction of 20th century mathematics—through naming problems that most wanted attention—was the great German mathematician David Hilbert. Quadratic forms with any algebraic numerical coefficients. . Hilbert's … Pogorelov (1973; [a34]). This list has been a programme for the development of mathematics ever since. mathematical treatment of the axioms of physics. Even in its original formulation, this problem splits into two parts. After Hilbert's death, another problem was found in his writings; this is sometimes known as Hilbert's 24th problem today. See also Formalism, Formal system, Axiomatic method, Consistency, Proof theory, and Unsolvability. , Amer. Hilbert's tenth problem. Here's a list of Hilbert's 23 problems from the write-up of his lecture, although only ten of them were included in the lecture itself. Conjecturally, the densest packing in three-dimensional space is the lattice packing $A_3$, the face-centred cubic. David Hilbert - Riemann hypothesis - International Congress of Mathematicians - Smale's problems - Continuum hypothesis - Fields Medal - Hilbert's third problem - Mary Frances Winston Newson - Clay Mathematics Institute - Hilbert's fifth problem - Hilbert's second problem - Hilbert's fourth problem - Ignoramus et ignorabimus - Hilbert's sixth problem - Hilbert's seventh problem - Hilbert's tenth problem - Hilbert's ninth problem - Mathematics - … The Handbook of Algebra will publish articles as they are received and thus the reader will find in this third volume articles from twelve different sections. Golomb, "Tiling rectangles with polyominoes", H. Heesch, "Aufbau der Ebene aus kongruenten Bereiche", J. Hirschfeld, "The nonstandard treatment of Hilbert's fifth problem", R.-P. Holzapfel, "The ball and some Hilbert problems" , Birkhäuser (1995), Yu. In one sense, b) was settled by K. Reinhardt (1928, [a36]), who found an anisohedral tiling in $\mathbb{R}^3$, and H. Heesch (1935, [a17]), who found a non-convex anisohedral polygon in the plane that admits a periodic monohedral tiling,. See also Elliptic partial differential equation; Boundary value problem, elliptic equations. Hilbert subsequently extended this list to twenty-three questions, known as “Hilbert’s Problems” (Hilbert & others, 1902). Il'yashenko, "Finiteness theorems for limit cycles" , Amer. If no apparent singularities are permitted and the underlying vector bundle must be trivial, there are counterexamples; see [a5] for a very clear summing up. This asks for the classification of quadratic forms over algebraic number fields. The numbers in question are of the form $\alpha^\beta$ with $\alpha$ an algebraic number and $\beta$ an algebraic irrational number. I. (1995), J.-M. Kantor, "Hilbert's problems and their sequels". Hilbert’s Tenth Problem Andrew J. Ho June 8, 2015 1 Introduction In 1900, David Hilbert published a list of twenty-three questions, all unsolved. Bernshtein (1903) and, in more or less definite form, by I.G. One of the main goals of Hilbert’s program was a finitistic proof of the consistency of the axioms of arithmetic (the 2nd problem). a) Show that there are only finitely many types of subgroups of the group $E(n)$ of isometries of $\mathbb{R}^n$ with compact fundamental domain. Proof of the finiteness of certain complete systems of functions. What new methods and new facts in the wide and rich field of mathematical thought will the new centuries disclose?” (David Hilbert, 1900). The precise form of the problem is as follows: Let $K$ be a field in between a field $k$ and the field of rational functions $k(x_1,\ldots,x_n)$ in $n$ variables over $k$: $k \subset K \subset k(x_1,\ldots,x_n)$. Hilbert's description is a bit … Problem . At least in the mainstream media, the de facto 21st century analogue of Hilbert's problems is the list of seven Millennium Prize Problems chosen during 2000 by the Clay Mathematics Institute. A famous list of 23 open problems, called "Hilbert's problems", was compiled in 1900 by German mathematician David Hilbert. Principles of Mathematical Logic represents one of Hilbert's important contributions to that debate. Although symbolic logic has grown considerably in the subsequent decades, this book remains a classic. He decided not to give a “ceremonial lecture” in which he would talk about what he had achieved so far in mathematics, nor to respond to Henri Poincaré‘s lecture at the first international mathematics congress in 1897, which had talked about the relationship between mathematics and physics. of a diophantine equation (brought about because of everyone's inability 1 - Cantor's problem of the cardinal number of the continuum. This article was adapted from an original article by M. Hazewinkel (originator), which appeared in Encyclopedia of Mathematics - ISBN 1402006098. Equal content and equal shape, figures of, Local-global principles for the ring of algebraic integers, Boundary value problem, elliptic equations, Boundary value problem, complex-variable methods, Boundary value problem, ordinary differential equations, Boundary value problem, partial differential equations, Boundary value problems in potential theory, https://encyclopediaofmath.org/index.php?title=Hilbert_problems&oldid=42960, Mathematics education and popularization of mathematics, "Die Hilbertschen Probleme" P.S.

Birmingham Flashscore, Kesu Ee Veedinte Nadhan Wiki, Judson University Football Location, Blenheim Bomber Crash Today, Best Surgical Oncologist In Usa, Antwerp Giants Basketball Score, Mechatronics Engineering Scholarship, Duke Medical School Graduation 2021, 1620: A Critical Response To The 1619 Project,